Case 838


April 26, 2016


University of Toronto v J.E.

Hearing Date(s):

March 28, 2016

Panel Members:

John A. Keefe, Chair
Graeme Hirst, Faculty Member
Sean McGowan, Student Member


Tina Lie, Assistant Discipline Counsel
Mr. J.E., the Student
David Pond, Instructor of the Course

In Attendance:

Krista Osbourne, Administrative Assistant, Appeals, Discipline and Faculty Grievances
Lucy Gaspini, Manager, Academic Integrity & Affairs, Office of the Dean, University of Toronto Mississauga

Student charged with two offences under s. B.i.1(d) and, in the alternative, two offences under s. B.i.1(b) and two offences under s. B.i.3(b) of the Code. The charges related to allegations that the Student submitted two separate Essays with significant elements of plagiarism, portions of which were reproduced verbatim from internet sources, and which sometimes contained reference to the internet source without the proper quotations or footnoting. The Student pleaded guilty to both plagiarism charges. The University then withdrew the four alternative charges. The Panel took into account the fact that the Student attended the hearing, that he had no prior offences, and that though the plagiarism was extensive, there was some independent thought in the essays and some attempt to reference the sources of the information. The Panel noted that the main aggravating factor was that the second plagiarized Essay was submitted after the allegations of plagiarism concerning the first essay had already been raised, but not finally disposed of. In reviewing the cases submitted, the Panel noted that the range of penalties for a first offence of plagiarism was two to three years. The Panel contemplated whether the case was on the high or low end of the plagiarism spectrum, settling on a penalty in the mid-range of sanctions for a first-time offender on a charge of plagiarism. The Panel noted that the penalties were to run concurrently for both charges (i.e. the charges were treated as a single offence). The Panel imposed a grade assignment of zero in the Course; a 2-year and 5-month suspension; a 4-year notation on the Student’s academic record and transcript; and that the case be reported to the Provost for publication.